You are currently viewing What Type of Pool Should I Get? Pros and Cons of the 3 Main Types

What Type of Pool Should I Get? Pros and Cons of the 3 Main Types

Imagine a hot summer day, and you’re longing for a refreshing dip in the pool. But what type of pool should I get? Which swimming pool fits your home, lifestyle, and budget best? Fret not because we’re here to help you navigate the world of pools and make an informed decision. In this blog post, we’ll discuss the pros and cons of the three main types of pools: above-ground, vinyl liner, and fiberglass, as well as concrete (gunite) pools. Let’s dive in!

  • When selecting a pool type for your home, consider maintenance requirements, installation time and durability to make an informed decision.
  • Assess budget and desired features such as size, color & design. Also, consider available space in the backyard.
  • Above-ground pools offer cost-effectiveness with quick installation but limited options. Vinyl liner pools are customizable & budget-friendly. Fiberglass pools have low maintenance needs, while concrete (gunite) provides high customization and long-term value.

Above Ground Pools: An Affordable Option

If you’re looking for a cost-effective way to bring the joy of swimming to your backyard, above-ground pools may be the perfect solution. These pools are not only more budget-friendly than in-ground options like concrete and fiberglass pools, but they also offer a variety of benefits that make them a popular choice for pool owners. Compared to an inground swimming pool, above-ground pools provide families with a more affordable and versatile option.

However, understanding the drawbacks before finalizing your decision is beneficial.

Benefits of Above-Ground Pools
Above-ground pools are known for their affordability and ease of installation. While in-ground pools can take weeks or even months to install, above-ground pools can be up and running in just a few days. This means you’ll be able to enjoy your new pool sooner and with less disruption to your daily life.

In addition to their lower initial costs, above-ground pools offer several advantages:

  • They require less maintenance than in-ground pools, making them more cost-effective in the long run.
  • They offer flexibility, as they can be easily tailored to various shapes and sizes.
  • They can be removed or relocated as needed.

Drawbacks of Above-Ground Pools
While above-ground pools have their advantages, they also come with some limitations. One of the most significant drawbacks is their limited design options compared to in-ground pools, such as concrete or fiberglass pools. Above-ground pools typically come in standard shapes and sizes, which may not suit every homeowner’s preferences.
Moreover, above ground pools generally have a shorter lifespan than in-ground pools, with some lasting as little as 5-10 years. This means that you may need to replace your pool more frequently than with an in-ground option. Additionally, above-ground pools can negatively impact your property value, whereas a well-maintained in-ground pool can increase it.

Vinyl Liner Pools: Customizable and Budget-Friendly

A vinyl liner pool is another popular option for homeowners seeking a swimming pool. These pools feature a custom-made vinyl sheet that acts as a barrier between the water and the pool structure, providing swimmers with a smooth and comfortable surface. Vinyl liner pools offer a combination of customization and cost-effectiveness, making them an attractive choice for many homeowners.

However, like any pool type, deciding if a vinyl liner pool suits your home requires weighing the pros and cons.

Advantages of Vinyl Liner Pools
One of the most significant benefits of vinyl liner pools is their lower material costs than other pool types like concrete or fiberglass pools. This cost-effectiveness extends to their maintenance requirements, as vinyl liner pools typically require less electricity and fewer chemicals for upkeep.

In addition to their cost benefits, vinyl liner pools offer a high degree of customization. Homeowners can choose from various shapes, sizes, and designs to create a pool that perfectly fits their needs and preferences. The smooth texture and nonabrasive surface of vinyl liners also contribute to a more comfortable swimming experience.

Disadvantages of Vinyl Liner Pools
While vinyl liner pools offer numerous benefits, they also come with some drawbacks. One of the main disadvantages is their shorter lifespan compared to other pool types like concrete or fiberglass pools. Vinyl liners typically need to be replaced every 5-10 years, which can add to long-term costs.

Another drawback of vinyl liner pools is their potential lack of aesthetic appeal. The appearance of the liner material may not be as visually pleasing as other pool types, such as a smooth, seamless fiberglass surface or the classic look of a concrete pool. However, modern vinyl liners have come a long way and now offer various patterns and colors that can enhance the pool’s overall appearance.

Fiberglass Pools: Low Maintenance and Quick Installation

Fiberglass pools are pre-fabricated fiberglass swimming pools made from fiberglass and resin. They offer a unique combination of low maintenance and quick installation, making them an attractive option for homeowners looking for a hassle-free pool experience. Additionally, fiberglass pools can be enhanced with various features and finishes to create a visually appealing and functional backyard oasis.

However, as with other pool types, homeowners should thoughtfully consider the pros and cons unique to fiberglass pools.

Benefits of Fiberglass Pools
Fiberglass pools are renowned for their minimal maintenance requirements. Here are some reasons why:

  • Their smooth, non-porous surface reduces algae growth
  • They are easier to clean than other pool types like concrete or vinyl liner pools
  • They are compatible with salt systems, which further simplifies pool upkeep

Another significant advantage of fiberglass pools is their speedy installation process. Because they are pre-fabricated, they can be installed in a few days, compared to the weeks or months it may take to construct a concrete or vinyl liner pool. This means you can start enjoying your new pool sooner, with minimal disruption to your daily life.

Drawbacks of Fiberglass Pools
Despite their many benefits, fiberglass pools also have some limitations. One of the most notable drawbacks is their size and design restrictions. Since fiberglass pools are pre-fabricated, they cannot be customized in terms of shape, size, or depth, limiting homeowners’ design choices. The maximum size of a fiberglass pool is typically 40 feet long and 16 feet in width.

While these size limitations may not deter some homeowners, they are worth considering when contemplating a fiberglass pool. If you desire a larger or more uniquely shaped pool, a concrete or vinyl liner option may better fit your needs.

Concrete (Gunite) Pools: Durable and Highly Customizable

Concrete (gunite) pools are constructed using a rebar framework that is sprayed over with a concrete and sand mixture, creating a solid and durable structure. These pools are highly customizable and can be designed to fit any shape, size, or depth desired by the homeowner. Some advantages of concrete pools include:

  • High level of customizability
  • Durability
  • Ability to add features such as waterfalls, slides, and diving boards
  • Long lifespan

These factors make concrete pools a popular choice for many homeowners.

However, as with all pool types, considering a concrete pool for your home involves weighing the pros and cons.

Advantages of Concrete Pools
One of the main benefits of concrete pools is their virtually limitless design options. Homeowners can create a pool that perfectly suits their needs and preferences, incorporating features such as tanning ledges, waterfalls, and even custom-designed shapes. This flexibility allows for a truly personalized backyard oasis to enhance your home’s aesthetic appeal and boost its resale value.

Concrete pools are known for their:

  • Durability
  • All-weather resilience
  • Long-lasting investment for homeowners
  • Ability to withstand various climatic conditions

This ensures years of enjoyment for pool owners with a well-maintained pool surface.

Disadvantages of Concrete Pools
While concrete pools offer many advantages, they also come with some downsides. One of the main drawbacks is their high maintenance requirements. Algae can adhere to the rough surface of a concrete pool, requiring more chemicals and effort to maintain water chemistry. This can lead to higher long-term costs for pool owners.

Concrete pools have a longer installation time than other pool types like vinyl liners or fiberglass pools. The construction process can take several weeks, if not months, to complete, depending on the design’s complexity and the pool’s size. This extended timeline may not be ideal for homeowners who want to start enjoying their pool as soon as possible.

Comparing Pool Types: Key Factors to Consider

Considering the pros and cons of each pool type, several key factors warrant consideration when deciding on the best pool for your home. These factors include maintenance requirements, installation time, and durability. By carefully weighing these factors, you can decide which pool type will best suit your needs, preferences, and budget.

In the following sections, we’ll delve into each of these key factors, comparing the three main pool types to assist you in making an optimal decision for your home.

Maintenance Requirements
Maintenance requirements vary among the different pool types, with fiberglass pools typically requiring the least amount of upkeep. Their smooth, non-porous surface reduces algae growth and makes them easier to clean than other pool types like concrete or vinyl liner pools. Above-ground pools also require less maintenance than their in-ground counterparts, making them a more cost-effective option for many homeowners.

On the other hand, concrete pools necessitate more maintenance due to algae adhering to their rough surface and their alkaline nature, which can elevate pH levels and require regular acid additions to balance. Vinyl liner pools also require regular cleaning and maintenance to keep the liner in good condition.

Installation Time
Installation time is another crucial factor to consider when choosing a pool type. Here is a breakdown of the installation times for different pool types:

  • Fiberglass pools: These pools offer the quickest installation time, as they are pre-fabricated and can be installed within a few days to three weeks.
  • Vinyl liner pools: These pools typically have an installation time of 6 to 8 weeks.
  • Concrete pools: These pools may take several weeks to several months to install, depending on the design’s complexity and the pool’s size.

If you’re eager to start enjoying your new pool as soon as possible, a fiberglass pool may be the best option. However, if you’re willing to wait for a more customized design, a concrete or vinyl liner pool may be more suitable for your needs.

Durability and Lifespan
Durability and lifespan are also essential factors to consider when choosing a pool type. Concrete pools are the most durable option, providing a solid, long-lasting structure that can withstand various climatic conditions. However, they also require the most maintenance, which can impact long-term costs.

In contrast, fiberglass pools offer moderate durability and require minimal maintenance, making them a popular choice among homeowners looking for a balance between durability and ease of upkeep. Vinyl liner pools also provide a long lifespan, although they are not as durable as concrete or fiberglass pools and require regular liner replacement.

Choosing the Right Pool for Your Home

With a thorough understanding of each pool type’s pros, cons, and critical factors, you’re better equipped to decide on the best pool for your home. To help you further refine your decision, consider assessing your budget, evaluating desired features, and considering the available space in your backyard.

By carefully weighing your options and preferences, you can confidently choose the perfect pool that will bring years of enjoyment and relaxation to your home.

Assessing Your Budget
Determining your budget is a crucial first step in deciding which pool type best fits your financial situation. The initial cost of a pool can vary greatly depending on the type, with:

  • Fiberglass pools typically cost between $45,000 to $85,000
  • Concrete pools ranging from $50,000 to $120,000
  • Vinyl liner pools are generally more affordable, with installation costs ranging from $35,000 to $65,000.

It’s also important to consider long-term costs, such as maintenance, repairs, and liner replacements for vinyl liner pools. By assessing your budget and comparing the costs of different pool types, you can determine the most cost-effective option for your needs.

Evaluating Desired Features
Once you’ve assessed your budget, take the time to evaluate the features you desire in a pool. Consider factors such as:

  • Size
  • Color
  • Type
  • Design
  • Water features
  • Lighting
  • Pool automation
  • Pool cover
  • Landscaping features

For example, if you desire a highly customized pool with unique features like tanning ledges or waterfalls, a concrete pool may be the best option for you. On the other hand, if you prioritize low maintenance and quick installation, a fiberglass pool may be more suitable.

By evaluating your desired features, you can better narrow down which pool type will best meet your needs and preferences.

Considering Available Space
Finally, consider the available space in your backyard when choosing a pool type. Assessing the size and layout of your outdoor area will help you determine the appropriate pool size and design that best suits your property. As a general rule, the pool and the pool surrounds should take up approximately 25% of the overall outdoor area.

Considering available space, you can ensure that your chosen pool type seamlessly integrates into your backyard and enhances your outdoor living experience.


In conclusion, choosing the right pool for your home involves carefully considering factors such as cost, desired features, available space, maintenance requirements, installation time, and durability. By thoroughly evaluating the pros and cons of each pool type, you can make an informed decision that best suits your needs and preferences. We hope this guide has provided valuable insights and information to help you confidently choose the perfect pool for your home. Happy swimming!

Frequently Asked Questions

How do I choose the right pool?
Choosing the right pool requires you to assess your needs, consider your budget, evaluate your backyard space, determine the pool’s shape, consider the number of swimmers, think about the pool’s depth, and consider maintenance and cleaning. Also, consider factors like the sun’s path, safety features, colors and textures, and any additional features when making your decision.

What type of pool is most cost-effective?
Vinyl liner pools have the lowest initial cost, usually ranging from $35,000 to $65,000, making them the most cost-effective option. Homeowners can also customize these pools into various shapes and designs.

What type of pool lasts the longest?
Concrete pools are the most popular and highly customizable choice, making them the best option for investing in a long-lasting pool. They will last much longer than vinyl liners or fiberglass pools with proper care and maintenance.

What are the types of pools?
Four main types of pools are available to consider: above-ground, vinyl-liner in-ground, fiberglass in-ground and concrete in-ground. Each has its own construction style and cost considerations.

What are the maintenance requirements for the three primary types of pools?
Above-ground pools require regular cleaning and upkeep, vinyl liner pools need routine maintenance, while fiberglass pools are the least demanding in terms of maintenance.

Leave a Reply